we all played it bad
In a $20+2 SNG, I was dealt AJo in early position.
I had about 1,000 chips; the blinds were 50/100, and there were 7 players (including me) remaining.
I hadn't played a hand in more than two laps, and the three maniacs who had started at our table had busted out. I was in about 3rd chip position, and the chip leader -- with about 1600 -- was in the small blind.
I open-raised all-in, figuring to take down the blinds. Given my position, chip stack, and that I hadn't played a hand in a while, I figured I would win the blinds uncontested.
Bad figuring.
A short stack called all-in with just under 600 chips, and the small blind went all-in.
The big blind folded, and the hands were turned up.
JJ for the small blind, ATo for the short stack. I was in trouble needing one of the two remaining aces to win.
As it turned out, an ace hit the flop and I took down the pot, knocking out the short stack, crippling the chip leader and becoming the chip leader in the process. I went on to take first in the tourny.
But, in thinking about this hand, I don't like any of it.
First, open-raising all-in with AJo is a bad play. Given my position, it was likely AQ, AK or a pocket pair could have been left to act, putting me in a bad spot. I could have limped, then folded if there was a big raise, or open-raised a smaller amount. Also, given the blinds and my stack, I could have simply folded the hand. AJo is tempting to play, and it will win its share of pots, but it's no powerhouse, esp out of position. I overplayed it and got very lucky.
The short stack calling all-in with ATo was a horrible play. He still had a couple of hands before he would be the big blind, and given that I hadn't played a hand in a while, it was too likely that my hand dominated his (which it did).
Also, he wasn't the smallest stack at the table, and had plenty of chips to cover his big and small blinds when it was his turn, and still have chips left over with which to pick his spots.
Calling all-in with ATo against an early position raiser in a game that is not shorthanded is just bad poker.
I also don't like the small blind getting involved here with JJ. While JJ can be powerful in shorthanded play or with position, this was a questionable spot. By folding, he loses his small blind, and lets two smaller stacks tangle. At the end of the hand, either one player is eliminated, or a stack that can hurt him has been diminished. He called against one of the few stacks that could hurt him, and after another player had already called.
You could argue that given the pre-flop raise and call, it was more likely that the Jacks were facing two players holding aces, making the jacks more of a favorite, but it could have been as likely that the Jacks were facing AQ in one spot and KK in another (or some other lethal combination).
Regardless, while Jacks are a strong hand, the chip leader didn't need to get involved, esp since there were still 7 players in the tournament.
Note that there is a huge difference in betting all-in with JJ and calling two players who are already all-in with JJ.
I think few players would fold JJ in this spot, hoping to take down a big pot, knock out two players and be in a strong position to win the tournament. And, the jacks were the favorite hand to win this pot, though pushing small edges isn't the best way to get into the money. Given that even if he lost, he would still have about 600 chips, he might have decided to gamble. But, in order to take first place in a tournament, you don't need to knock out every player, just the last one. Folding here allows two smaller stacks to tangle, possibly eliminating one, and putting you one step closer to the money. And that's a strong play.